Competition Films I Have Seen:Ranked in order of preference   My Palme d'Or: Synecdoche, New York (USA, dir. Charlie Kaufman) - Should feel relentless, a moraine of phlegmatic despondency; sometimes it does, but wit, ambition, density, sincerity render it sublime (full review) Lorna's Silence (Belgium, dirs. Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne) - Have awaited a Dardennes film that grew allegory out of organic story, rather than vice versa; here it is, a beauty! Iffy ending, though The Class (Entre les murs) (France, dir. Laurent Cantet) - Last act too busily plotted, yet still feels empty; you only notice because first 80% astonishes with detail, insight, vivid ambivalence A Christmas Tale (France, dir. Arnaud Desplechin) - For about first hour, I was rapt, thinking no one blends the filmic and the novelistic like this; it plateaued, but I still savored it Gomorrah (Italy, dir. Matteo Garrone) - Takes a while to fire up, and Garrone is hardly a born image-maker, but quite a bit lingers, especially broad sense of malignant congestion The Headless Woman (Argentina, dir. Lucrecia Martel) - Martel's framing and ellipticism are as nervy as ever, though she seems too much to be "doing Martel"; film still merits its stalwart champs Waltz with Bashir (Israel, dir. Ari Folman) - Film amasses real impact, though final move wasn't to my taste; less opaque, thick-lined animation might have made sense, but it still lands (full review) Che (USA, dir. Steven Soderbergh) - I appreciated slantwise approach to Che's ascendancy and oddly mundane collapse, but clearly too long, with so-so lensing, uncertain insight Three Monkeys (Turkey, dir. Nuri Bilge Ceylan) - We've seen slate-gray skies and sweaty brows before, and eerie ghost thread just dangles, but huzzah to Ceylan's newfound sense of humor (full review) Adoration (Canada, dir. Atom Egoyan) - Only Khanjian and Egoyan could devise this morosely insane drama teacher, a ripe if dubious conceit against which rest of film pales (capsule review) Blindness (Brazil/USA, dir. Fernando Meirelles) - Doesn't wrong the book so much as seems wholly superfluous; vague sense of local idiom but story still works; Moore quietly strong Delta (Hungary, dir. Kornél Mundruczó) - Artfully lensed, with some creeping power, but too many moves swiped from Festival Handbook of Slow-Build Morbidity (full review) Two Lovers (USA, dir. James Gray) - Opening scene is most formally arresting and most poignant; film is okay, but Nice Brunette/Crazy Shiksa setup seems awfully ...old (capsule review) Changeling (USA, dir. Clint Eastwood) - Harshest detractors undersell its better moments, but much worse when Eastwood devotees give pass to uneven acting, design, and story (full review) My Jury Votes:
Sidebar Selections I Have Seen:Ranked in order of preference   Hunger (Un Certain Regard: UK, dir. Steve McQueen) - Should more visual artists try narrative cinema? Do they all see this compellingly? Wobbly end, show-offy pas-de-deux, but rest all thrills Johnny Mad Dog (Un Certain Regard: France/Belgium/Liberia, dir. Jean-Stéphane Sauvaire) - Yes, it risks sensation, but only a fraction as much as City of God did, and this one's scarier, weirder, and more tautly assembled Wendy and Lucy (Un Certain Regard: USA, dir. Kelly Reichardt) - There's artful minimalism, and there's flannel copy of same; ratio here about two to one, though my uneasiness with Williams persists Of Time and the City (Special Screening: UK, dir. Terence Davies) - Some of the footage entrances, but match of image to narration often slim; why bother with modern day if it makes him so flatly cranky? Tyson (Un Certain Regard: USA, dir. James Toback) - Say this for Mike: he's lived a lot and is capable of saying surprising things, but that's no reason to leave his POV totally unchecked Vicky Cristina Barcelona (Out of Competition: USA/Spain, dir. Woody Allen) - Allen's jokey high-school book report on Unbearable Lightness of Being, based largely on fast-forwards to favorite scenes from the film (full review) Tokyo! (Un Certain Regard: Japan/France/South Korea, dirs. Michel Gondry, Leos Carax, and Bong Joon-ho) - Gondry bit seems thin but improves; Bong's seems dopey and gets worse; Carax's is shit-stained grenade launched from subterranean alien civ Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (Out of Competition: USA, dir. Steven Spielberg) - One could lament creaky Ford, or can't-let-go fans who demanded this, but it's Spielberg you worry about: he thinks this is good enough? Competition Films I'm Curious to See: Ranked in order of interest; more on this year's lineup here (opens in a new window)   Frontier of Dawn, France, dir. Philippe Garrel 24 City, China, dir. Jia Zhangke Linha de Passe, Brazil, dirs. Walter Salles and Daniela Thomas Lion's Den/Leonera, Argentina, dir. Pablo Trapero Serbis, The Philippines, dir. Brillante Mendoza Il Divo, Italy, dir. Paolo Sorrentino
Sidebar Films I'm Curious to See: Listed alphabetically; more on this year's lineup here (opens in a new window)  
|