Competition Films I Have Seen:Ranked in order of preference   My Palme d'Or 4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days (Romania, dir. Cristian Mungiu) - Excellent, fresh, suspenseful; phenomenally assured acting and direction, and mature collapsing of any line between politics and "real life" We Own the Night (USA, dir. James Gray) - Unpretentiously gripping police thriller is also subtle, daring, and formally rigorous: a world-class revisiting of B-movie idioms Alexandra (Russia, dir. Aleksandr Sokurov) - Sokurov may have visual and thematic tics but they work so richly and never seem insincere; a new species of oneiric war film The Edge of Heaven (Germany, dir. Fatih Akin) - Template of intertwining lives seemed exhausted, but this well-shot, well-acted, well-written drama is elegant and emotionally direct Secret Sunshine (South Korea, dir. Lee Chang-dong) - Uneven contrivances, less bracing than Oasis, but still a gutsy, restlessly agnostic maternal melo. Jeon is great. Zodiac (USA, dir. David Fincher) - Fantastic in concept and retrospect, if somewhat wearying and patchy in the moment; kudos for playing smartly against serial-killer grain (full review) The Mourning Forest (Japan, dir. Naomi Kawase) - Enigmatic and austere in story, but gorgeous in color and crystalline in structure; not for everyone, but why won't niche distribs touch it? No Country for Old Men (USA, dirs. Joel and Ethan Coen) - Coens adapt script in register of philosophical ambition and direct with mind on brute suspense; both tracks engage but don't always jell Silent Light (Mexico, dir. Carlos Reygadas) - Lensing as ace as you've heard, almost as if fishing for compliments; story barely supports such meticulous filming, but easily worth a look The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (France, dir. Julian Schnabel) - Another bio from Schnabel that accommodates gifts for color, light, flamboyant show-pieces, cloaking shaky script and iffy grasp of structure Persepolis (France, dirs. Marjane Satrapi and Vincent Paronnaud) - Visually ingratiating with well-written scenes; not filmmakers' fault that they can't presume informed audience, but feels a bit low-balled Paranoid Park (USA, dir. Gus Van Sant) - Van Sant's apex? Really? Fine work, but sonic, visual, and montage motifs from preceding films pushed too insistently, hung on weak story Death Proof (USA, dir. Quentin Tarantino) - Can't handle this without merry Planet Terror to build up good will; formal tension soured by bloated first hour, unsettling glee in sadism My Blueberry Nights (USA/Hong Kong, dir. Wong Kar-wai) - Implies intriguing potentials for Wong amid looser community, under bigger sky, but mostly clichéd; actors elated to be cast but driftless The Last Mistress (France, dir. Catherine Breillat) - Drably costumey, momentum stalled, story threadbare, Argento and Aattou flat; only Claude Sarraute works, but her role is too confined My Jury Votes:
Sidebar Selections I Have Seen:Ranked in order of preference   You, the Living (Un Certain Regard: Sweden, dir. Roy Andersson) - Andersson's tableaux mordants are ingeniously contrived but also accumulate rich, surprising poignancy along with howling laughs Zoo (Directors' Fortnight: USA, dir. Robinson Devor) - Tasked to build doc around wholly obfuscated incident, Devor resists judgment and reimagines the form, achieving eerie, lyrical ghost story A Mighty Heart (Out of Competition: UK/USA, dir. Michael Winterbottom) - So much more than an Oscar play or "biopic"; Jolie, film both smart and wrenching, with director's usual acumen for taking global pulse Savage Grace (Directors' Fortnight: USA, dir. Tom Kalin) - Key is not to expect psychological penetration of lurid real-life tale; film thrills as a series of sharp, hot, opaque stabs at its subject Flight of the Red Balloon (Un Certain Regard: France, dir. Hou Hsiao-hsien) - Glassy remoteness of other Hou films livens a bit here; who'd have guessed he was the man to loosen up Binoche so gloriously? Boarding Gate (Out of Competition: France, dir. Olivier Assayas) - Maintains auteur's fascination with creepy side of modern, global industry, but a self-conscious retreat from demonlover ambitions Control (Directors' Fortnight: UK, dir. Anton Corbijn) - Dwindles into tweedy Wife vs. Girlfriend conflict, but Corbijn finds continuity and contrast between punk highs and working-class anomie (full review) Ocean's Thirteen (Out of Competition: USA, dir. Steven Soderbergh) - Gang refreshed from Twelve but still missing Eleven magic; Barkin an unnerving presence; color, light raised to avant-garde abstraction The 11th Hour (Special Screening: USA, dirs. Nadia Conners and Leila Conners Petersen) - Makes potent, hard-to-argue case about ecology on brink of collapse; mere weeks later, though, hard to recall one image not of Leo Jellyfish (Critics' Week: Israel, dirs. Etgar Keret and Shira Geffen) - Like a short-story collection alternating among realist and lightly abstracted modes; piquant, uneven, but grows on you Terror's Advocate (Un Certain Regard: France, dir. Barbet Schroeder) - Assembly somewhat scattershot, as though Schroeder is encountering significant limits in access, though this augments creepy thesis XXY (Critics' Week: Argentina, dir. Lucía Puenzo) - Gutsy, candid portrait of intersexed teen, though film needs more shaping; not sure about sea life as key metaphor, but film looks good (full review) Sicko (Out of Competition: USA, dir. Michael Moore) - Starts with some of Moore's best-ever footage and explication, before giving way to outrageous and frankly insulting simplifications The Band's Visit (Un Certain Regard: Israel, dir. Eran Kolirin) - An appealing film, and absolutely nothing wrong with cozying up to a broad audience; charming but tiny, with no sense of excitement Competition Films I'm Curious to See: Ranked in order of interest; more on this year's lineup here (opens in a new window)   Import/Export, Austria, dir. Ulrich Seidl The Man from London, Hungary, dir. Béla Tarr The Banishment, Russia, dir. Andrei Zvyagintsev Breath, South Korea, dir. Kim Ki-duk Love Songs, France, dir. Christophe Honoré
Sidebar Films I'm Curious to See: Listed alphabetically; more on this year's lineup here (opens in a new window)  
|